Wed 8 Aug 2007
With Elected Officials Like These, Who Needs Enemies
Posted by Karen J. Adams under General[11] Comments
The Republicans have been pushing the message that taxes and government are inherently bad and since Reagan, they have been on a tax cutting spree for the extremely wealthy and cost cutting spree on budget items that directly effect the majority, average Americans.
As we have industrialized, we built an infrastructure. Government is necessary for these monumental projects like the early canal system and then the railroads. Individuals cannot possibly do these things on such a grand scale. Even if government didn’t pay for the entire project, it was necessary for right of ways, coordination through different jurisdictions, etc. Since the 1930′s under the WPA, we have been building massive projects like bridges, dams, sewer systems, electric grids like the TVA, and airports and an interstate highway system starting in the 1950′s. None of this would have been possible without government and taxes.
Maintenance and replacement on critical infrastructure like bridges, dams and levies has been delayed or denied. I remember a bridge on I95 in Connecticut collapsed in the 80′s. ( used to drive over it a couple of times a year and hated that stretch so much, I took another route). The army corps of engineers reported that the levies around New Orleans wouldn’t protect the city in a severe hurricane. The bridge on I35, like too many of our bridges, was reported to be in very bad shape. The sewer and water pipes in our major cities are very old and break all the time, disrupting major downtown areas. I just checked out an interactive map on msnbc’s website, www.msnbc.com/id/20093413/. It shows shows each state’s bridge ranking. How comforting to know now that I am living in Pennsylvania that we and only one other state (I think it’s Massachusetts) have the worst bridges in the country. You can check out the bridges by county. I did. I shouldn’t leave my house.
I am not even writing about decrepit schools and other public buildings, but infrastructure that endangers our lives everyday. I have traveled in Europe quite a bit and their transportation systems are more technologically advanced. They invest their money, their taxes, into systems that will make their lives more convenient and safe and their economies run.
I don’t know about you, but my taxes have gone up not down over the last 25+ years. The services the government provides have declined. We have lost a whole American city, a cultural gem. Bridges are falling with cars sitting bumper to bumper during rush hour. A steam pipe exploded in Manhattan, a rainstorm shuts down the subway. The power grid in northern Ohio and southern Michigan shut down about four years ago for several days in the summer. Even the water supply was effected. Public transportation in this country is shrinking. Trains seem to derail on a regular basis, sometimes endangering communities by spilling some kind of dangerous cargo. We are told there is just not enough money for us, for the things that make our society technologically advanced, convenient, efficient and safe.
But there seems to be funds, billions for no bid contracts. Contracts that are supposed to provide clean water and meals to our troops and rebuild Iraq but don’t. Billions of dollars are missing in Iraq too, and apparently there is no accounting system to figure out where the money went. It seems a lot of American supplied arms are missing in Iraq now. What a way to support our troops.
Billions spent on the global war on terrorism, on the Iraq and Afghanistan war and yet terror acts have increased world wide and Bin Laden is still roaming the Pakistan border. 1800 people died during Katrina. Homeland Security employees are looking at airline passengers’ deodorant and hair gel in plastic bags while bridges collapse and steam pipes explode.
I hate when politicians treat Americans like they are stupid. People understand they must pay taxes. What people hate is corruption and wasting their tax money. The Democrats weren’t free from waste and fraud but the Republicans have raised it to a whole new universe. People want and therefore will pay for sound bridges. People will pay for maintenance because they know it’s cheaper than structural failure. People want to live in an advanced society not one declining into something medieval.
We need to dispel the meme that government doesn’t work and that it is unnecessary, bad. Without good government, people fall overboard.

Mr. Editor – I figured out how to add a link!
Awwww… your first link. Mazel Tov!
Neither Party has had the courage to take on the Pentagon. Even for modern day progressives it is still considered political suicide to not “support the troops” by voting for billion s on pointless overpriced weapon systems.
Eventually American’s are going to have to get smart and demand that their Representatives represent them instead of defense contractors.
Thank you.
Your point is too true. The European Common Market and Japan do not spend anywhere close to what the U.S. spends in defense. So much more of their revenue goes to domestic spending and it shows. I never researched China and Russia. It would be interesting to find out what is defense spending compared to GNP under Putin compared to his immediate predecessor and what was it during the cold war. I would settle for accountability right now. Where is all the money going in the Pentagon budget? During any war, there should be a contract oversight board to investigate profiteering. There was one during WWII and if that administration had the time and ability to oversee government contracts during a world war, we can certainly do it now.
Here are some interesting statistics from the The Center for Arms Control & Proliferation
As a percent of GDP, there are a few small countries that out spend the U.S. See RANK ORDER, MILITARY STATISTICS – CIA FACTBOOK
Russian estimates are uncertain, so not included in the CIA Factbook (unless I am looking right at it and missing it). Certainly military spend as % GDP has fallen from the Soviet days in which 25%-40% went to military. I think it has averaged 2.5-4% of GDP in the past ten years, with reported budget increases of ~25% per year for 2006 and 2007.
Long time lurker (since the primary for the special election in 2005), first time commenting.
This is right on. I have no problems paying taxes. I would pay more taxes for more services. But I want those services to benefit my country, not a few corporations. It makes me so mad to hear Republicans talk about how they are making our country stronger and safer while our infrastructure, the very things we need to live our day to day lives, are literally crumbling below our feet.
I whole heartedly agree that this country’s infrastrcture is in shambles. The Republicans and Democrats have been raping Social Security and the Highway Trusts for years. They have continued to run the country without a balnced budget and further funding of their Earmarks. I have commented on my website about this, using the I-75 Bridge here in Cincy as an example. It’s a shame there has to be a loss of life before our government takes action.
Kudos on a great post Karen!
Randy Longbottom
2008 Congressional Candidate
Debra the Economist – thank you for digging out the statistics. That’s what’s so great about these internet tube things. People with all kinds of backgrounds and skills fill in the blanks. It would have taken me forever and I wouldn’t have been sure I had the correct information.
It’s very sobering information. I always think of all the things we could do with the funds, quality of life issues. How much better our public education could be, healthcare, research institutions, transportation, etc. How much time and hassle would be saved if we had high speed rail in certain high traveled corridors and what that would do for our economy. I worry about lack of funding for basic research. We are losing are premiere place in the world in advance technological research. Is that what we want?
The interesting thing about statistics and numbers is, you can spin them one way or another and make a case for or against something. For example, the current Congress loves to point out the fact that un-employment numbers are low. What does that mean? Americans are gainfully employed and making good wages? No, it means that there is a small percentage of people currently collecting benefits from the un-employment office. They fail to mention that the number of working poor is ever increasing and that the American wage growth number has been negative since 2005. Leading to record numbers of Bankruptcies and Home Forclosures.
So when you say “As a percent of GDP, there are a few small countries that out spend the U.S.” and I look at that data and see that in fact 26 countries outspend America as a percentage of GDP. I say, well that really isn’t that bad. We spend less than 5% of the GDP on the military, where does the other 95% go? Well it’s not really fair to use percent of GDP as an indicator either. America’s GDP dwarfs all others. The GDP isn’t what the government has to spend anyway. Instead we should look at the Military Spending as a percentage of the current budget. Also keep in mind that military spending equates to millions of jobs in this country as well. It also includes college tuition for millions of veterans that would not otherwise be afforded the oppurtunity to get an education. Here is a site that does a great job of filtering the data:
http://www.citizenjoe.org/node/418
For the record, I’m not saying we shouldn’t cut government waste and put it towards research, healthcare, and education. What I am saying, is let’s make sure we have all the data and compare apples to apples.
Randy Longbottom
2008 Congressional Candidate
That’s why I don’t cite statistics – because I want an apple to apple comparison. I wasn’t curious about our military budget compared to GNP but the old USSR military spending compared to their GNP.
I’d like to know about the black budget (I think that’s what they call it), the one that is about all the classified military and CIA operations.
I agree with you, Randy. Overall GDP spend is a better measure. And the U.S. is definitely the top dog. Among the few small countries with higher military spending per GDP, there were a few scary ones.
Regarding Black Budget, here’s what I found on Wikipedia:
The United States Defense Department has a “black budget” it uses to fund expenditures it does not want to disclose publicly. Such an expenditure is called a “black project.” The annual cost of the United States Defense Department black budget is estimated at $40 billion by some watchdogs, but some critics believe it to be much higher ($1.5 trillion – Philip Schneider), fed by funds funneled from other government agencies to the defense and intelligence community.
Note: The Schneider estimate sounds way out there, much like many of his other claims.
What would be really interesting (and scary) would be to see the items in the current administration’s black budget compared to past administrations’ black budget. Do you think certain things have been moved to the black budget to hide the spending from Congress?